American Gold Buffalo price on eBay right now

Across 50 live Buy It Now listings for "American Gold Buffalo" on eBay US, the market median is $4,790. Half of listings sit between $4,737 and $5,003. Rescanned every 6 hours; last sweep 2026-09-04 23:25 UTC.

76% underbuy now

2008-W PCGS MS69 American Gold Buffalo $5 - 1/10 oz BEAUTIFUL

$1150market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

74% underbuy now

Rare 2008 W $5 American Gold Buffalo .9999 1/10 oz NGC MS70

$1250market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

46% underbuy now

2008-W American Gold Buffalo 1/4 Oz .9999 US Mint $10 Unc OGP COA

$2599market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

35% underbuy now

2008-W American Gold Buffalo Proof 1/2 Oz .9999 US Mint $25 OGP COA

$3100market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

26% underbuy now

2008-W American Gold Buffalo Proof 1/2 Oz .9999 US Mint $25 OGP COA

$3549market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

25% underbuy now

2008-W American Gold Buffalo Proof 1/2 Oz .9999 US Mint $25 OGP COA

$3599market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

2% underbuy now

1 oz American $50 US Gold Buffalo Coin BU (Random Year) .9999 Fine-Pre-Sale

$4695.2market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

2% underbuy now

$50 American Gold Buffalo 1 oz Random Year Brilliant Uncirculated

$4698.82market $4790

instant buyBuy It Now

100% underauction

Golden American Buffalo w/ COA Merrick Mint + 3 Coin Lot #1

$10market $4790

1 bids...

100% underauction

Golden American Buffalo w/ COA Merrick Mint + 3 Coin Lot #2

$10market $4790

0 bids...

100% underauction

First Silver Penny Racketeer Gold Nickel Set American Frontier Nickel Buffalo +

$9.99market $4790

0 bids...

The median is the middle asking price of live Buy It Now listings for this exact search, so it reflects what sellers are asking today, not what buyers paid last month. Use the 25th percentile as a realistic quick-sale price and the 75th as a patient-seller price. Anything listed well under the 25th percentile is worth checking for condition, completeness, and seller feedback before you buy.