Squishmallow rare price on eBay right now
Across 50 live Buy It Now listings for "Squishmallow rare" on eBay US, the market median is $40. Half of listings sit between $30 and $75. Rescanned every 6 hours; last sweep 2026-10-10 06:01 UTC.
Cheapest Buy It Now right now
37% underbuy nowSquishmallows Na'lma Hummingbird 🆕 RARE Plush Pink Green White Flowers 8" NWT
34% underbuy nowSquishmallows FuzzAMallow Official 16 inch Charles the Green Pickle with Mustach
35% underbuy nowSquishmallows Sam Dog 16” Large Brown Plush BNWT Rare Kellytoy Collectible
34% underbuy nowHarry Potter Squishmallows Plush w/ Tag Wizarding World Kellytoy 8in RARE w/Tags
34% underbuy now8" Rochelle the Squirrel Orange Purple Blue Pink Squishmallow - RARE HTF NWT!
34% underbuy nowSquishmallow 17” NORA Fairy Butterfly Plush Large Stuffed Toy RARE Original
32% underbuy nowRare Original Squishmallows 10" Cannon Halloween Treat Pail NWT 2025 So Cute
32% underbuy nowSquishmallow 2024 Ms. K the Clown 10 inch Exclusive Rare Plush Halloween..NEW
Auctions under market, ending within 24h
90% underauctionSquishmallows Pegasus Flying Pig Pink Kellytoy Wings 18" (Rare) Super Soft
77% underauctionOriginal Squishmallows Hello Kitty And Friends Kuromi Halloween 8" w/ Tag RARE
75% underauctionNEW SQUISHMALLOW 5” LEONARD THE RAINBOW LION CLAIRE’S EXCLUSIVE NWT HTF RARE
70% underauctionNEW SQUISHMALLOW 7” CHASE THE MINT GREEN TABBY KITTEN CAT KELLYTOY NWT HTF RARE
70% underauctionNEW SQUISHMALLOW 7” WARREN THE TAN BROWN WILD BOAR WILDLIFE SQUAD NWT HTF RARE
50% underauctionNEW Squishmallow Cece The Birthday Cat Claire's Exclusive Rare Plush 5" w/Hat 7"
49% underauctionNWT 12” Squishmallows Connor Cow Plush White Black Pink RARE BANTER TOYS UK EXCL
47% underauctionRARE NWT Carowinds Green Hornet 8" Fury 325 Squishmallow Bright Green
Price history
Price by condition
| condition | median | listings |
|---|---|---|
| New | $37 | 40 |
| Pre-owned | $50 | 10 |
28% of current listings are promoted by the seller, which usually signals a motivated seller rather than a bargain. Compare against the condition medians above, not the overall median, before deciding a price is good.
What moves lego & collectible toys prices
LEGO prices are driven by retirement status, sealed versus opened, and completeness. A retired set in a sealed box appreciates for years; the same set built with the box gone can be worth a third of that. Set numbers are the only reliable identifier because names get reused. For vintage toys, original packaging and unpunched cards multiply value. Hot Wheels and Funko prices depend on variant and exclusivity codes.
How to read this
The median is the middle asking price of live Buy It Now listings for this exact search, so it reflects what sellers are asking today, not what buyers paid last month. Use the 25th percentile as a realistic quick-sale price and the 75th as a patient-seller price. Anything listed well under the 25th percentile is worth checking for condition, completeness, and seller feedback before you buy.