Buffalo nickel price on eBay right now
Across 50 live Buy It Now listings for "Buffalo nickel" on eBay US, the market median is $49. Half of listings sit between $30 and $129. Rescanned every 6 hours; last sweep 2026-10-18 19:00 UTC.
Cheapest Buy It Now right now
47% underbuy now[Lot of 40] Buffalo Nickels No Date / Low Grade - Choose How Many Lots of 40!
47% underbuy now1920-P Buffalo Nickel Choice Original XF/AU Full Horn
47% underbuy nowCOOL OLD GROUP OF 32 BUFFALO NICKELS~Various Years, Mints & Cond.~MOST VERY NICE
45% underbuy nowComplete Full Date Buffalo Nickel Set 9 Coins 1926P-1937P
47% underbuy now1913-1938 Buffalo Nickels 20-Coin Roll (Full Dates)
46% underbuy now1938-D USA 5c Buffalo Nickel Nice Brilliant Uncirculated
42% underbuy now1938-D USA 5c Buffalo Nickel Choice Brilliant Uncirculated
39% underbuy now(5) Buffalo Nickel VF-XF Very Fine-Extremely Fine Estate Fine
Auctions under market, ending within 24h
98% underauctionESTATE FIND 1927 BUFFALO NICKEL!!! #F3225
98% underauction1913-1938 Buffalo Nickel 5C Philadelphia Mint Business Strike KM#134 Cu-Ni
96% underauction1919- Buffalo Nickel #P35288
96% underauction1926- Buffalo Nickel #P35289
96% underauctionEstate Find 1936 Buffalo Nickel #K63711
94% underauctionEstate Find 1928 S- Buffalo Nickel!! #K56959
94% underauctionEstate Find 1934 D- Buffalo Nickel!! #K56958
92% underauction1 Oz. Solid .999 Fine Copper Round - Buffalo Nickel - Golden State Mint
Price history
Price by condition
| condition | median | listings |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-owned | $49 | 49 |
28% of current listings are promoted by the seller, which usually signals a motivated seller rather than a bargain. Compare against the condition medians above, not the overall median, before deciding a price is good.
What moves coins & bullion prices
Bullion prices track spot metal plus a premium that varies by product and dealer; sovereign mint coins carry higher premiums than bars. Numismatic coins price on date, mint mark and grade, and a slab from PCGS or NGC is what separates a collector price from a bullion price. Cleaned coins lose most of their collector premium. Lots and rolls price per coin, so compare on a per-ounce or per-coin basis.
How to read this
The median is the middle asking price of live Buy It Now listings for this exact search, so it reflects what sellers are asking today, not what buyers paid last month. Use the 25th percentile as a realistic quick-sale price and the 75th as a patient-seller price. Anything listed well under the 25th percentile is worth checking for condition, completeness, and seller feedback before you buy.