Buffalo nickel price on eBay right now

Across 50 live Buy It Now listings for "Buffalo nickel" on eBay US, the market median is $55. Half of listings sit between $35 and $100. Rescanned every 6 hours; last sweep 2026-09-04 23:23 UTC.

52% underbuy now

1913-1938 Buffalo Nickels 20-Coin Roll (Full Dates)

$26.17market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

51% underbuy now

Complete Full Date Buffalo Nickel Set 9 Coins 1926P-1937P

$26.95market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

51% underbuy now

Complete Buffalo Nickel Set of 9 Full Date Indian Head Nickel Coins 1926P-1937P

$26.95market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

45% underbuy now

Count of Ten Circulated Buffalo Nickels 1913-1938 Fine - Random Date

$29.82market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

45% underbuy now

Full Date US Buffalo Nickels - Lot of 20 - Circulated - Great Mix!!

$29.95market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

45% underbuy now

Full Date US Buffalo Nickels - Lot of 20 - Circulated - Great Mix!!

$29.95market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

45% underbuy now

SHARP Tougher Date 1915-P BUFFALO NICKEL 5¢ Free S&H! LF51EW

$29.95market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

45% underbuy now

No Date Buffalo Nickels - 100 Coins from 1913-1938

$29.99market $55

UngradedBuy It Now

99% underauction

USA 5 CENTS 1934

$0.69market $55

1 bids...

99% underauction

USA 5 CENTS 1935

$0.69market $55

1 bids...

98% underauction

1937 US Indian Head Buffalo Nickel FULL DATE Rare 89 Year Old Collection Coin

$1.25market $55

4 bids...

98% underauction

Lot of 18 Buffalo Nickels -Random Year, Random Condition, Random Mint

$1market $55

2 bids...

96% underauction

1930 Buffalo Nickel 5C Five Cents Coin Philadelphia Mint Business Strike

$2market $55

0 bids...

95% underauction

1927 Buffalo Nickel Indian Head 5¢ Type Nice Fine Coin~~Free Shipping.

$2.77market $55

0 bids...

95% underauction

1924 (P) Indian Head Buffalo Nickel Average Circ *8205

$2.95market $55

0 bids...

95% underauction

Buffalo Nickel Lot Of 14 Mixed S & D 1926-1937

$2.82market $55

5 bids...

The median is the middle asking price of live Buy It Now listings for this exact search, so it reflects what sellers are asking today, not what buyers paid last month. Use the 25th percentile as a realistic quick-sale price and the 75th as a patient-seller price. Anything listed well under the 25th percentile is worth checking for condition, completeness, and seller feedback before you buy.