Indian Head penny price on eBay right now

Across 50 live Buy It Now listings for "Indian Head penny" on eBay US, the market median is $46. Half of listings sit between $40 and $85. Rescanned every 6 hours; last sweep 2026-09-04 23:24 UTC.

41% underbuy now

1909 Indian / BU Wheat On End Estate Sale ~ Unsearched Cents US Coins ~ One Roll

$26.95market $46

instant buyBuy It Now

37% underbuy now

OLD COPPER LOT! INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNIES 1858-1909 COLLECTIBLE ESTATE LOT 5 COIN

$28.5market $46

UngradedBuy It Now

36% underbuy now

30 EACH INDIAN HEAD CENT CULLS

$28.95market $46

UngradedBuy It Now

35% underbuy now

1861 Copper Nickel Indian Head Cent Nice Civil War Era Coin

$29.5market $46

UngradedBuy It Now

34% underbuy now

1861 Indian Head Cent Penny 1c - *Cleaned* - Good/Very Good (G/VG)

$29.95market $46

UngradedBuy It Now

34% underbuy now

1863 Indian Head Penny Cent Coin F Condition Nice Coin

$30market $46

UngradedBuy It Now

30% underbuy now

16 diff 1859-1909 INDIAN HEAD CENT SET COLLECTION new whitman folder LOT

$32market $46

UngradedBuy It Now

23% underbuy now

🔥 LARGE COLLECTION OF INDIAN HEAD CENT PENNY COINS 🔥ESTATE SALE 🔥U GET 10!

$34.95market $46

UngradedBuy It Now

96% underauction

1889 Indian Head Cent Penny USA Coin

$1.99market $46

0 bids...

95% underauction

US Rare Old West 1882 Indian Head Penny Coin American Collection Shield Cent USA

$2.25market $46

10 bids...

95% underauction

1901 INDIAN HEAD CENT,MOST OF LIBERTY, NICE COIN!!!!(A9)

$2.5market $46

0 bids...

95% underauction

US Rare Old 1880 Indian Head Penny Coin Native American Collection Shield Cent

$2.25market $46

7 bids...

94% underauction

1900 Indian Head Cent AC Average Circ *0024

$2.95market $46

1 bids...

93% underauction

Antique 1923 USA LIBERTY "INDIAN HEAD / BUFFALO NICKEL" Five Cent Circulated (b)

$3market $46

0 bids...

93% underauction

Antique 1928 USA LIBERTY "INDIAN HEAD / BUFFALO NICKEL" Five Cent Circulated

$3market $46

0 bids...

93% underauction

Antique 1919 USA LIBERTY "INDIAN HEAD / BUFFALO NICKEL" Five Cent Circulated (a)

$3market $46

0 bids...

The median is the middle asking price of live Buy It Now listings for this exact search, so it reflects what sellers are asking today, not what buyers paid last month. Use the 25th percentile as a realistic quick-sale price and the 75th as a patient-seller price. Anything listed well under the 25th percentile is worth checking for condition, completeness, and seller feedback before you buy.